brown #
= weekly rock chart peak
blue #
= pop chart peak
| 1 | September In The Rain | 1937 |  |
| James Melton |
| 2 | September In The Rain | 1937 | |
| Guy Lombardo And His Orchestra with Carmen Lombardo |
| 3 | September In The Rain | 1937 | |
| The Rhythm Wreckers with Pauline Byrne |
| 4 | September Song | 1939 | |
| Walter Huston with Maurice De Abravanel Orchestra |
| 5 | September Song | 1947 | |
| The Dardanelle Trio |
| 6 | September Song | 1947 | |
| Frank Sinatra with Axel Stordahl Orchestra |
| 7 | September In The Rain | 1948 | |
| Sam Donahue And His Orchestra |
| 8 | September In The Rain | 1949 | |
| George Shearing Quintet |
| 9 | September Song | 1951 | |
| Stan Kenton And His Orchestra |
| 10 | September Song | 1952 | |
| Liberace |
| 11 | My September Love | 1956 | |
| David Whitfield With The Roland Shaw Orchestra |
| 12 | September In The Rain | 1956 | |
| Julie London With Pete King And His Orchestra |
| 13 | September Song | Jan 1958 | |
| Billy Ward And His Dominoes |
| 14 | See You In September | 10 | Sep 1959 | |
| The Tempos |
| 15 | Theme From Come September | Aug 1961 | |
| Santo & Johnny |
| 16 | Come September | Nov 1961 | |
| Billy Vaughn And His Orchestra |
| 17 | Theme From Come September | Nov 1961 | |
| Bobby Darin & His Orchestra |
| 18 | September In The Rain | Dec 1961 | |
| Dinah Washington |
| 19 | It Might As Well Rain Until September | 20 | Sep 1962 | |
| Carole King |
| 20 | September Song | Oct 1963 | |
| Jimmy Durante |
| 21 | September In The Rain | Sep 1965 | |
| Chad & Jeremy |
| 22 | Sweet September | Dec 1965 | |
| The Lettermen |
| 23 | See You In September | 1 | Aug 1966 | |
| The Happenings |
| 24 | See You In September | Nov 1967 | |
| Santo & Johnny |
| 25 | Thirty Days Hath September | Sep 1968 | |
| Robert Goulet |
| 26 | September Blue | Oct 1968 | |
| Pat Boone |
| 27 | September Song | Oct 1969 | |
| Roy Clark |
| 28 | See You In September | Jul 1972 | |
| The Mike Curb Congregation |
| 29 | Wait Until September | Sep 1973 | |
| Michael Allen |
| 30 | It Might As Well Rain Until September | Jul 1974 | |
| Gary And Dave |
| 31 | It's September | Oct 1974 | |
| Johnnie Taylor |
| 32 | September Gurls | 1974 | |
| Big Star |
| 33 | September | 4 | Feb 1979 | |
| Earth, Wind & Fire |
| 34 | September Song | May 1979 | |
| Willie Nelson |
| 35 | See You In September | Sep 1979 | |
| Debby Boone |
| 36 | September Morn' | 8 | Feb 1980 | |
| Neil Diamond |
| 37 | Let's Groove (Medley): 1. In The Stone 2. Star 3. September 4. Boogie Wonderland 5. I've Had Enough 6. Can't Let Go 7. Let's Groove | Mar 1984 | |
| Mirage |
| 38 | September Song | Dec 1984 | |
| Ian McCulloch |
| 39 | September Grass | Apr 2003 | |
| James Taylor |
| 40 | Wake Me Up When September Ends | 1 | 3 | Oct 2005 | |
| Green Day |
| 41 | September | Oct 2005 | |
| Spoken |
| 42 | September | Feb 2010 | |
| Gabriela Anders |
| 43 | September | 14 | Nov 2010 | |
| Daughtry |
| 44 | Make It Stop (September's Children) | 4 | Aug 2011 | |
| Rise Against |
| 45 | Blame It On September | Oct 2011 | |
| Allstar Weekend |
| 46 | September Fields | Nov 2014 | |
| Frazey Ford |