brown #
= weekly rock chart peak
blue #
= pop chart peak
| 1 | I Can't Help It (If I'm Still In Love With You) | 1952 |  |
| Guy Mitchell With Mitch Miller And His Orchestra |
| 2 | I Can't Help It (If I'm Still In Love With You) | Nov 1962 | |
| Johnny Tillotson |
| 3 | I Can't Help It (If I'm Still In Love With You) | May 1967 | |
| B.J. Thomas |
| 4 | I'm Still In Love With You | 3 | Aug 1972 | |
| Al Green |
| 5 | Still In Love | Aug 1985 | |
| Taxxi |
| 6 | Still In Love | Mar 1987 | |
| Jaki Graham |
| 7 | Can'tcha Say (You Believe In Me)/Still In Love | 5 | 26 | Apr 1987 | |
| Boston |
| 8 | Still In Love | Feb 1989 | |
| Troop |
| 9 | Still In Love | Nov 1989 | |
| Stage Dolls |
| 10 | Still In Love With You | May 1992 | |
| Meli'sa Morgan |
| 11 | Still In Love | Apr 1993 | |
| Go West |
| 12 | I'm Still In Love With You | Jun 1994 | |
| Al B. Sure! |
| 13 | Still In Love | Jan 1996 | |
| Brian McKnight |
| 14 | Still In Love | Nov 1996 | |
| Lionel Richie |
| 15 | I'm Still In Love With You | 6 | Jan 1997 | |
| New Edition |
| 16 | Still In Love Song | Apr 2004 | |
| The Stills |
| 17 | I'm Still In Love With You | 5 | Apr 2004 | |
| Sean Paul Featuring Sasha |
| 18 | Still In Love | May 2004 | |
| Teena Marie Featuring Baby |
| 19 | Still In Love | Sep 2005 | |
| Warren Hill |
| 20 | Still In Love | Feb 2006 | |
| Tyra B. |
| 21 | Still In Love With You | Jun 2011 | |
| Sade |