brown #
= weekly rock chart peak
blue #
= pop chart peak
| 1 | Stay | Aug 1958 |  |
| The Ames Brothers |
| 2 | Stay | 1 | Nov 1960 | |
| Maurice Williams & The Zodiacs |
| 3 | Stay | Feb 1964 | |
| The Hollies |
| 4 | Stay | 12 | Mar 1964 | |
| The 4 Seasons |
| 5 | Stay | Jul 1976 | |
| David Bowie |
| 6 | Stay | Jan 1977 | |
| Andrew Gold |
| 7 | Stay | Jun 1978 | |
| Rufus Featuring Chaka Khan |
| 8 | The Load-Out/Stay | 8 | Aug 1978 | |
| Jackson Browne |
| 9 | Stay | Jan 1980 | |
| Bruce Springsteen, Jackson Browne & The E-Street Band with Rosemary Butler |
| 10 | Stay | May 1982 | |
| Barry Manilow |
| 11 | Stay | May 1982 | |
| Ray, Goodman & Brown |
| 12 | Stay | Apr 1986 | |
| Oingo Boingo |
| 13 | Stay | Apr 1986 | |
| The Controllers |
| 14 | Stay | Feb 1992 | |
| Jodeci |
| 15 | Stay | Aug 1992 | |
| Giant |
| 16 | Stay | 3 | Sep 1992 | |
| Shakespear's Sister |
| 17 | Stay | Jul 1993 | |
| Kenny Thomas |
| 18 | Stay (Faraway, So Close!) | 12 | Jan 1994 | |
| U2 |
| 19 | Stay | 4 | Mar 1994 | |
| Eternal |
| 20 | Stay (I Missed You) | 19 | 1 | Jul 1994 | |
| Lisa Loeb & Nine Stories |
| 21 | Stay | Jun 1995 | |
| Dreamhouse |
| 22 | Stay (Tonight) | Jul 1995 | |
| Isha-D |
| 23 | Stay | Feb 1996 | |
| 60ft Dolls |
| 24 | Stay | Mar 1997 | |
| 18 Wheeler |
| 25 | Stay | Jan 1998 | |
| Bernard Butler |
| 26 | Stay | Mar 1998 | |
| Sash! Featuring La Trec |
| 27 | Stay | May 1998 | |
| Mica Paris |
| 28 | Stay (Wasting Time) | 6 | Aug 1998 | |
| Dave Matthews Band |
| 29 | Stay | Oct 1998 | |
| The Temptations |
| 30 | Stay | Mar 2000 | |
| Alison Krauss |
| 31 | Stay | Feb 2004 | |
| Cyndi Lauper |
| 32 | Stay | Jul 2004 | |
| Rob Tissera, Vinylgroover & The Red |
| 33 | Stay | Sep 2004 | |
| Jeremy Camp |
| 34 | Stay | Oct 2004 | |
| David Guetta Featuring Chris Willis |
| 35 | Stay | Jul 2005 | |
| Sarah Bettens |
| 36 | Stay | Oct 2005 | |
| Ne-Yo Featuring Peedi Peedi |
| 37 | Stay | Jul 2006 | |
| Swati |
| 38 | Stay | Oct 2007 | |
| Simply Red |
| 39 | Stay | Nov 2007 | |
| Sugarland |
| 40 | Stay | Jul 2008 | |
| Jay Sean |
| 41 | Stay | Mar 2009 | |
| Gavin DeGraw |
| 42 | Stay | 28 | Jul 2009 | |
| SafetySuit |
| 43 | Stay | Feb 2010 | |
| Nick Jonas & The Administration |
| 44 | Stay | May 2010 | |
| BoDeans |
| 45 | Stay | Jul 2010 | |
| Miley Cyrus |
| 46 | Stay | Nov 2010 | |
| Hurts |
| 47 | Stay | Nov 2011 | |
| Tyrese |
| 48 | Stay | Nov 2011 | |
| Diego Garcia |
| 49 | Stay | May 2012 | |
| Mayday Parade |
| 50 | Stay | 1 | Apr 2013 | |
| Rihanna Featuring Mikky Ekko |
| 51 | Stay | May 2013 | |
| Amber Carrington |
| 52 | Stay | Nov 2013 | |
| Infection's |
| 53 | Stay | Dec 2013 | |
| Florida Georgia Line |
| 54 | Stay | Jul 2014 | |
| No Devotion |
| 55 | Stay | Aug 2014 | |
| Thirty Seconds To Mars |