| 1 | Mary's Boy Child | Dec 1956 |  |
| Harry Belafonte |
| 2 | Mary's Boy Child | Dec 1957 | |
| Gracie Fields |
| 3 | Mary's Boy Child | Dec 1957 | |
| Bob Dale |
| 4 | Mary's Boy Child | Dec 1959 | |
| Roger Williams |
| 5 | Mary's Little Boy Child | Dec 1963 | |
| Jim Reeves |
| 6 | Mary's Little Boy Child | Dec 1965 | |
| Andy Williams |
| 7 | Mary's Little Boy Child | Dec 1966 | |
| The Lettermen |
| 8 | Mary's Boy Child | Dec 1970 | |
| Rolf Harris |
| 9 | Mary's Boy Child | Dec 1970 | |
| The Ramsey Lewis Trio |
| 10 | Mary's Little Boy Child | Dec 1990 | |
| John Denver |
| 11 | Mary's Boy Child | Dec 1993 | |
| David Foster with Tom Jones |
| 12 | Mary's Little Boy Child | Dec 2003 | |
| Harry Connick, Jr. |
| 13 | Mary's Boy Child | Dec 2011 | |
| TobyMac Featuring Jamie Grace |