blue #
= weekly pop chart peak
| 1 | I Let Her Go | 1953 |  |
| Frankie Laine |
| 2 | (Why Did I Ever) Let Her Go | Feb 1958 | |
| The Techniques with Hugo Peretti Orchestra |
| 3 | Let Her Go | Jun 1965 | |
| Peggy March |
| 4 | Never Let Her Go | 20 | Mar 1975 | |
| David Gates |
| 5 | Let Her Go | May 1982 | |
| Point Blank |
| 6 | Let Her Go | Apr 1991 | |
| Mark Collie |
| 7 | Can't Let Her Go | Jul 1998 | |
| Boyz II Men |
| 8 | Let Her Go | Nov 2013 | |
| Cole Vosbury |
| 9 | Let Her Go | 2013 | |
| Jasmine Thompson |
| 10 | Let Her Go | 2 | Feb 2014 | |
| Passenger |